The planner is working. All verification gates are clear.

Real browser captures and recorded checks now cover the integrated shell, editing workflows, state and local plus hosted persistence.

7/7core workflows verified

4passing quality gates

0open verification items

Current product

Captured from the integrated build

Browser evidence

Bayplan desktop editor showing the room, catalogue, three-dimensional canvas, scene list and inspector — **Integrated desktop editor**Full planning shell at 1280 × 720

Bayplan isometric view with a selected warehouse object repeated in the viewport and inspector — **Selection identity**Selected state across canvas, scene and inspector

Bayplan top camera preset showing the measured warehouse floor grid — **Measured top view**Preset camera with metre grid and room dimensions

Bayplan close-up showing a selected double door with two leaves, handles and clearance arcs — **Door planning**Single and double doors with visible swing clearances

Bayplan showing two work desks selected as Group 1 with shared movement and rotation controls — **Grouped equipment**Multi-select, shared transforms and persistent group identity

Bayplan planning shell at 900 pixels wide — **900 px shell**Controls remain available

Bayplan deliberate small-screen fallback at 620 pixels wide — **620 px fallback**Deliberate read-only handoff

Responsive behaviour verified

The critic exercised the complete desktop editor, compressed laptop shell and intentional small-screen fallback.

Acceptance path

Core workflows

7 verified

01
Room changed from 12 × 8 × 3 m to 18 × 10 × 4 m with 12 objects retained.
02
Numeric X/Z and 37° edits, duplicate and remove were exercised through the inspector.
03
Save, reload, diverge and exact restore completed; work-desk-3 identity was preserved.
04
Canvas selection, direct drag, scene selection, focus, orbit, zoom and pan were exercised.
05
Desktop editor, 1024 px and 900 px shells, 620 px deliberate fallback, controls and feedback were verified.
06
Single and double doors were added, positioned, rotated, duplicated, removed, saved, reloaded and restored.
07
Two desks were grouped, moved, rotated, duplicated, removed and restored while retaining spacing and member identity.

Recorded checks

Tests & build

State testsReducer, grouping, doors and persistence sequence 10/10 pass

Focused lintCurrent application source Pass

Production buildOnly the recorded >500 kB chunk warning remains Pass

Full npm test3 rendered HTML/integration tests + 10 planner-state tests 13/13 pass

Independent review

Critic findings

Pass

State & persistence

12 × 8 × 3 → 18 × 10 × 4, 12 objects, numeric X/Z/37° editing, duplicate/remove, save, reload, diverge and exact restore all passed. Identity work-desk-3 survived the round trip.

State and persistence critic isometric evidence

Verified

Product shell

Desktop, 1024 px, 900 px and 620 px states, controls, keyboard feedback and this route loaded successfully. Its largest finding was that this evidence page was stale; the page is now populated, without claiming a critic re-grade.

Direct object drag during browser workflow verification

Pass

Three.js viewport

Recheck passed at 40 × 60 × 12 m and 18 × 10 × 4 m. Every preset, Focus, orbit, pan and zoom remained usable after preset-specific corner fitting, stronger grid and edge contrast, and revised fog. The console recorded 0 errors.

Viewport recheck showing the usable 40 by 60 by 12 metre isometric view

Pass

Clean-session integration

The fresh gauntlet passed with 12 objects, exact save/reload/restore, every camera preset and Focus path, orbit, pan and zoom at 1024 px. It recorded 0 console errors, npm test 10/10 and lint pass.

Exactly restored 12-object workspace from the final clean-session gauntlet

Open record

Remaining verification gaps

0 open

No open verification gaps. Hosted save, fresh-session reload and exact door restore passed in production.

Reference strip

The interface bar used during critique

Captured

Floorplanner interface reference — **Floorplanner**Quiet canvas and compact mode hierarchy

Rayon interface reference — **Rayon**Technical contrast and precise drafting language

Warehouse-Planner interface reference — **Warehouse-Planner**Operational geometry and warehouse specificity

SketchUp interface reference — **SketchUp**Recognisable camera and object controls